Re: [Ethereal-dev] dns-over-tcp reassembly problems

[Guy Harris <guy@xxxxxxxxxx>]

On Tue, Apr 02, 2002 at 01:41:56PM -0800, Brian Wellington wrote:
> When getting a response that spans multiple segments (dig for 
> huge.foo.xbill.org, if anyone wants to try it) and decoding it, I see
> 	[Short Frame: DNS]
> in the first segment, and
> 	[Unreassembled Packet: DNS]
> in the second (and last).  The 'Desegment all DNS packets' option is 
> enabled.

Is the TCP configuration option "Allow subdissector to desegment TCP
streams" option enabled?  If not, enabled it (and save your
configuration, so it stays on).

Ther are per-protocol options to control TCP reassembly, which default
to "on" (if they don't, that's a bug).

There's also a *global* option to control it, which is the TCP "Allow
subdissector to desegment TCP streams" option; both options must be on
for a particular protocol's data to be reassembled.  "Allow subdissector
to desegment TCP streams" defaults to "off".

If I turn that option off, with a "dig huge.foo.xbill.org" trace, I get
the behavior you describe.  If I don't, the reply gets reassembled.

> I don't see an obvious way to specify explicitly that these 
> segments are part of the same packet and should be decoded as such.

There isn't one.

If reassembly isn't enabled in both places, they *shouldn't* be decoded
as part of the same packet. 

If reassembly *is* enabled in both places, they should automatically be
decoded as part of the same packet; if they're not, that's a bug, and
the bug should be fixed.